Hollywood
has long had a fascination with the Mob. From the Humphrey Bogart
films of the 1940's to more recent films like Casino and Donnie
Brasco. Crime, murder, respect, betrayal...cosa nostra. These are the
things upon which great drama is built, and certain filmmakers were born
to bring these stories to the big screen. Coppola. Scorcese.
DePalma. Their names are synonymous with some of the best gangster
pictures ever made. Roughcut.com wondered what might have happened
if some of our favorite mob movies had been put in the hands of directors
who, though talented in their own right, aren't quite as well suited for
these stories of organized crime.
THE GODFATHER
The quintessential mob
movie directed by Francis Ford Coppola is an epic in every sense
of the word. But put into the hands of action director Michael Bay
(Bad Boys, Armageddon, The Rock), the film might've
played a little differently.

THE CAST
Vito Corleone
Bruce Willis
Michael Corleone
Ben Affleck
Sonny Corleone
Nicolas Cage
Fredo Corleone
Steve Buscemi
THE SCRIPT
FADE IN:
INT. DON CORLEONE'S HOME
OFFICE - DAY
BONASERA is seated in
front of the Don's desk.
BONASERA
|
|
So, will you
kill them? |
|
|
|
CUT TO: |
|
EXT. CORLEONE HOUSE -
DAY
The Don's daughter at
her wedding reception. The wedding cake EXPLODES sending cake flying all
over the guests.
|
|
CUT TO: |
|
INT. BEDROOM - MORNING
A man wakes up with a
horse's head just as it EXPLODES sending tiny bits of horse flesh all over
the room.
|
|
CUT TO: |
|
INT. RESTAURANT - NIGHT
Michael Corleone exits
the restroom and begins shooting. The room EXPLODES sending bits of cutlery,
wine bottles, and porcelain plates flying.
|
|
CUT TO: |
|
EXT. TOLLBOOTH - DAY
Sonny Corleone pays his
toll. Realizes something is wrong as the tollbooth EXPLODES sending shrapnel
flying. Several MEN with guns emerge and fire at Sonny's car causing
it to EXPLODE sending bits of metal flying into the air where they EXPLODE
into smaller bits.
|
|
CUT TO: |
|
EXT. GARDEN - DAY
Vito Corleone plays with
his young GRANDSON. He runs through the rows of the tomatoes, then collapses
as his heart EXPLODES inside his chest.
|
|
CUT TO: |
|
INT. DON CORLEONE'S HOME
OFFICE - NIGHT
Michael Corleone sits
behind the desk waiting for something to EXPLODE.
FADE OUT
|
|
GOODFELLAS
Martin Scorcese
created a memorable portrait of life in the mob with this Academy Award
nominated Best Picture. But what if George Lucas had taken on the
project instead?
|
|
THE CAST
James Conway
Harrison Ford
Henry Hill
Ewan McGregor
Tommy DeVito
CGI voiced by Ahmed Best
Karen Hill
Carrie Fisher
Paul Cicero
James Earl Jones
|
|
|
THE SCRIPT
INT.
RESTAURANT - NIGHT
A band of blue and green
CREATURES play a tune in the background as the fellas sit and drink. TOMMY
DEVITO a fluidly moving man with skin that looks like plastic and a face
that would look great on a t-shirt, bedsheets, or maybe a toothbrush is
finishing a story.
TOMMY
|
|
So Isa saysa
whatchu doing here? Isa tells you gosa fussa yous mommas. |
|
The table erupts with laughter.
HENRY
|
|
You're funny.
You're really funny. |
|
Tommy takes pause at this.
TOMMY
|
|
Whasa yousa
mean I's funny? |
|
HENRY
|
|
You're funny.
You know. It's a good story. It's funny. You're a funny guy. |
|
TOMMY
|
|
Whassa yousa
means I'sa funny? You meansa waysa talk? |
|
HENRY
|
|
It's just you
know, it's, you're just funny that's all. |
|
TOMMY
|
|
Funny's howsa?
Whassa funny's 'bout it? Am Isa a clownsa? I'sa here to amusa yousa? |
|
Henry is getting a little
nervous. Suddenly he hears a voice.
MAN'S VOICE (O.S.)
|
|
Use the force,
Henry. |
|
Henry looks to Tommy. Summons
up his courage.
HENRY
|
|
Get outta here. |
|
The table is silent. The
blue and green creatures on the stage stop playing their instruments. A
smile creeps onto Tommy's face. Did I mention his face would look good
on the side of a can of soda. Maybe even a bag of potato chips.
TOMMY
|
|
Isa almost
had 'im. |
|
The table erupts in laughter
and orders another round.
SCARFACE
Brian DePalma's
Scarface is dark, violent, and bloody as hell. But in the hands
of the Farrelly Brothers, things might have been, well, a little
sillier.
THE CAST
Tony Montana
Jim Carrey
Manny Ray
Randy Quaid
Elvira
Cameron Diaz
Gina
Lauren Holly
THE SCRIPT
INT.
TONY'S MANSION - NIGHT
Tony emerges from his
office as a swarm of MEN enter his home. He turns, bends over and grabs
his butt cheeks.
TONY
|
|
You wanna play
rough? Okay. You wanna play games? Okay. |
|
Tony turns around and unzips
his pants.
TONY
|
|
Say hello to
my little friend. |
|
The men in black duck for
cover. One of the men rises. Runs his fingers through his hair. His bangs
defy gravity. JONATHON RICHMAN steps out of the shadows and begins singing.
JONATHON
(singing)
|
|
He does too
many drugs. His friends are a bunch of thugs. But there's something about
Tony. |
|
FADE OUT
Needless to say, The
Godfather, Goodfellas, and Scarface would probably not
be deemed classics of the gangster genre if any of the above scenarios
had come true. Though, with the success of their latest films, it wouldn't
be surprising if Lucas, Bay, and the Farrelly Brothers were able
to convince a studio to give them millions to bring their version of life
in the Mafia to the big screen. Let's hope that doesn't happen. The rumors
about a Godfather IV are frightening enough.
For a look at the more
accurate portrayals of the mob in the movies, be sure to catch Family
Values: The Mob In Movies premiering August 24th on TNT.
M.
Meghan McCarthy
photo
credits: Goodfellas - Warner Bros.; The Godfather - Paramount; Scarface
- Universal; Jim Carrey - New Line; Jar Jar Binks - Lucasfilm; Nicolas
Cage - Vanity Fair; Bruce Willis - 20th Century Fox
|  |